Showing posts with label House of Commons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label House of Commons. Show all posts

Saturday, November 23, 2013

DID FOREIGN OFFICE MINISTER MISLEAD PARLIAMENT?


On Tuesday morning there was a mini-debate on Gibraltar in the House of Commons. It was not in the main chamber but in Westminster Hall and was opened by Jim Dobbin, the Labour – Co-op MP for Heywood and Middleton. He prefaced his words by stating his interest as he is also the Chairman of the all party group on Gibraltar.
Jim Dobbin, stood up at 11.00 and continued until 11.15. He frequently gave way so that other MPs - Labour, Conservative, DUP - could also have their say. Then at 11.15 the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, Mark Simmonds, spoke as well as answering MPs questions until 11.30.
So let us first set out what this meant in Gibraltar time. Here on the Rock Jim Dobbin took the floor at noon, sat down at 12.15, the minister then spoke from 12.15 to 12.30. The details of the debate can be checked in Hansard and I will post the link at the end of this article.
The MPs who took part in this debate were very knowledgeable on Gibraltar but were talking largely in the past tense. They spoke about the abuses over the summer, the EC Inspectors, the Guardia Civil shooting and so on and so forth but what they didn’t know as they questioned Mark Simmonds was that at that very moment a Spanish State vessel was sitting in British Gibraltar Territorial Waters and refusing to move. They didn’t know and Mark Simmonds didn’t tell them. Had they been aware of that fact then the comments addressed to the Minister would have been far more pointed, heated and angry.
So the question is this: did Mark Simmonds deliberately mislead the House by not coming to the debate and making a statement on the latest blatant incursion by a Spanish State vessel?

The Minister opened his statement by saying: “I congratulate the hon. Member for Heywood and Middleton (Jim Dobbin) on securing this important debate at such a significant time and on the articulate and passionate way in which he outlined his case.” Indeed but he didn’t tell Jim Dobbin, Bob Stewart, Caroline Dinenage, Martin Horwood, Ian Paisley, Simon Hughes and Robert Neil – the MPs whose questions he answered – just how “a significant time” it was.

Now to our own Government’s statement which was made on Tuesday afternoon. “The Government condemns the sustained incursion into British Gibraltar Territorial Waters (BGTW) by the Spanish state survey vessel RV “Ramon Margalef” yesterday and today and its dangerous navigation in our waters. The Government takes a very serious view of this development which represents yet another escalation of Spain’s campaign against Gibraltar on land and at sea.

“The lengthy duration of the illegal incursion, which lasted about 21 hours, is something new. …The latest serious development involved a Spanish state vessel remaining in British waters overnight and ignoring the warnings to get out issued by the Royal Navy. Indeed, the vessel came within 250 metres of the entrance to Gibraltar Harbour and sailed in close proximity to other ships at anchor in the Bay of Gibraltar. This led to a separate warning issued to them by the Gibraltar Port Authority on the grounds of safety to shipping.”

So the “Ramon Margalef” arrived on Monday, was ordered to leave by the Royal Navy which she refused to do, she stayed in British Gibraltar Territorial Waters overnight yet when the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, Mark Simmonds, addressed the House of Commons on Gibraltar at 11.15 on the Tuesday, (12.15 Gibraltar time) he failed to mention it.

There can only be two explanations for his actions. The first is that he was totally unaware of what was happening in British Gibraltar Territorial Waters in which case why is he the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs?

The second is that he deliberately misled the House on such an important matter by acting as if nothing had happened. If that is the case why is he still the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs?


Thursday, May 23, 2013

I SAW 176 UNLAWFUL SHIPS COME SAILING IN




I received an email from The Convent on Tuesday. My heart sunk: what have I written that’s upset them now? Nothing for once. Instead it was a link to Parliamentary Questions at which Gibraltar had been the subject.

The three I am going to quote you are from Jim Dobbin. He is the Labour MP for Heywood and Middleton and is one of the cross party Parliamentarians who ask informed questions of Ministers about Gibraltar. I remember meeting him at the Gibraltar Reception at the Labour Party Conference two years ago. 

The first question was: To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how many incursions into British Gibraltar territorial waters there have been over the last six months.

Well the Secretary of State didn’t reply but David Lidington, who is the Minister of State (Europe and NATO) at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, answered this one and the other two.

Lidington stated: There have been 176 unlawful incursions into British Gibraltar Territorial Waters by Spanish state vessels in the period from 1 November 2012 to 30 April 2013.

We will pause here whilst Danny “I see no ships” Feetham gets his abacus out and totals his own figures.

Whilst he does that I must admit I was surprised at the total which is just under 30 a month or around one a day.

Next Jim Dobbin wanted to know: “what steps he has taken to deter illegal incursions into British Gibraltar territorial waters by Spanish Civil Guard boats.”

To this David Lidington replied, although I doubt if he was at the helm himself “The Royal Navy challenges Guardia Civil vessels whenever they make unlawful incursions into British (BGTW). We also make formal diplomatic protests to the Spanish Government about all such incursions. We will continue to do all that is necessary to uphold British sovereignty over BGTW.”

When I am sure readers have their own views on that.

Finally Jim Dobbin asked the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how many times the Spanish Ambassador has been summoned to the Foreign Office over the last 12 months in respect of Spanish incursions into British Gibraltar territorial waters.

Now it is this reply that I find the most interesting. David Lidington told Jim Dobbin:  “The Spanish ambassador has been publicly summoned to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office once in the last 12 months in respect of unlawful incursions into British Gibraltar Territorial Waters by Spanish state vessels.”

So let us get this right: over a six month period there have been 176 illegal incursions by the Spanish State vessels into our waters which equates to around one a day. And how often has the Spanish Ambassador been summoned to the Foreign Office to explain these actions. The reply is once – in the last 12 months.

You will note the answer is once in the last 12 months, not six months, so in the last six months the answer could be no times at all.

Far be it from me to tell the Foreign and Commonwealth Office how to do its business. However if the Spanish Ambassador had been summoned to the Foreign Office basically every day for the last six months to explain his Government’s actions, maybe, just maybe, Spain would take the illegal incursions in to our waters a little more seriously.

Having said that I fear another email from The Convent is on the way.